5 Bethlehem Road

Callicoon Center, NY 12776

About this property

Escape the frantic pace of the city and settle into the restorative rhythm of country living. Perfectly positioned along a gentle, babbling stream, this classic 1930s bungalow captures timeless Americana with generous space and enduring vintage charm. An inviting enclosed front porch welcomes you inside to a light-filled living room that flows seamlessly into an expansive country kitchen, creating a warm, natural hub for morning coffee or evening gatherings. Practical country living is thoughtfully balanced throughout, complete with a rear deck that leads into a dedicated mudroom, ideal for peeling off boots after an afternoon exploring the grounds. With four-plus flexible bedrooms and a full bath, the layout effortlessly adapts to host family, weekend visitors, or dedicated creative workspaces. The true magic of this property, however, unfolds just beyond the threshold. Step outside to listen to the soothing murmur of the running water, gather around the fire pit beneath starlit skies, or duck into the freestanding creekside cabin with a good book for an afternoon of quiet contemplation. Located in the heart of a vibrant Western Catskills community, small-town life is right at your doorstep. Take a short stroll on warm Wednesday evenings to catch the historic Callicoon Center Band, dine nearby at Callicoon Hills' acclaimed Conover Club, or spend weekends exploring the revived North Branch Cider Mill and neighboring hamlets like Jeffersonville, Roscoe, and Callicoon. This is an authentic upstate sanctuary where simple pleasures take center stage.

About this property

Escape the frantic pace of the city and settle into the restorative rhythm of country living. Perfectly positioned along a gentle, babbling stream, this classic 1930s bungalow captures timeless Americana with generous space and enduring vintage charm. An inviting enclosed front porch welcomes you inside to a light-filled living room that flows seamlessly into an expansive country kitchen, creating a warm, natural hub for morning coffee or evening gatherings. Practical country living is thoughtfully balanced throughout, complete with a rear deck that leads into a dedicated mudroom, ideal for peeling off boots after an afternoon exploring the grounds. With four-plus flexible bedrooms and a full bath, the layout effortlessly adapts to host family, weekend visitors, or dedicated creative workspaces. The true magic of this property, however, unfolds just beyond the threshold. Step outside to listen to the soothing murmur of the running water, gather around the fire pit beneath starlit skies, or duck into the freestanding creekside cabin with a good book for an afternoon of quiet contemplation. Located in the heart of a vibrant Western Catskills community, small-town life is right at your doorstep. Take a short stroll on warm Wednesday evenings to catch the historic Callicoon Center Band, dine nearby at Callicoon Hills' acclaimed Conover Club, or spend weekends exploring the revived North Branch Cider Mill and neighboring hamlets like Jeffersonville, Roscoe, and Callicoon. This is an authentic upstate sanctuary where simple pleasures take center stage.

Features and Additional Information

Schedule a Tour
It's free and no obligation

Schedule a Private Showing

$289,000 Active
4 Bed(s)
1
Bath
1,294 sqft

Presented By Smitchger Realty

Agent Image
Get in touch today! Phone: 1-845-534-7874
Brokerage
Callicoon Real Estate LLC
1-845-887-4400
Curious to find out what your home is worth?
Get My Home's Worth arrow_forward

Area Information

| Sullivan County County |

$ 289,000
This listing is play_arrow 23.2% lower than the average in the area
$ 376,500 in the area
1,294 SqFt
This listing is play_arrow 38.5% smaller than the average in the area
2,105 SqFt in the area
$ 223 $/SqFt
This listing is play_arrow 16.7% more than the average in the area
$ 191 $/SqFt in the area
87 days on site
This listing is play_arrow 20.0% above the average in the area
73 days on site in the area

Schools in the Area

  • turned_in
    Elementary School
    Sullivan West Elementary
  • turned_in
    Middle School
    SULLIVAN WEST HIGH SCHOOL AT LAK
  • turned_in
    High School
    Sullivan West High School At Lak

Want to See More Listings in the Area?

Listed By Rosemarie S. DeCristofaro
Brokerage: Callicoon Real Estate LLC

Schedule a Private Showing

It's free and no obligation

Have Questions? Contact
Smitchger Realty

By submitting, you agree to receive promotional texts and/or calls from John J Lease Realtors at the number provided. Message/data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase, and you can opt out anytime by replying STOP.
Real Estate Links Our Domains